Ranking the Resident Evil “failures” that are actually worth playing
Resident Evil’s lowest-rated games you should play at least once
Resident Evil is an undeniable titan of the gaming industry. Over the past 30 years, Capcom has built a legacy of terror that has generated massive profits and a global fanbase. Most recently, the launch of Resident Evil Requiem on February 27, 2026, proved the series is stronger than ever. The title sold over 5 million copies in just five days, making it the fastest-selling entry in franchise history. Critics have also praised its dual-protagonist system, awarding it an impressive Metascore of 88.
However, even a master makes mistakes. Throughout its history, Resident Evil has seen experimental spin-offs and controversial mainline entries that failed to hit the mark with critics. Yet, many of these “failures” contain unique ideas or moments that every fan should experience at least once.
The Experimental Missteps: Survivor and Gaiden
Resident Evil Survivor was an early attempt to blend the series’ horror with light-gun shooter mechanics. Unfortunately, when it arrived in North America, the light-gun support was removed, forcing players to use a standard controller for a first-person experience. While criticized for its shallow plot and recycled assets, it remains an interesting artifact as the first RE game to explore a full 3D, first-person perspective.
Similarly, Resident Evil Gaiden for the Game Boy Color took the series into uncharted waters. It featured a non-canon story starring Leon S. Kennedy and Barry Burton on a ghost ship. The hardware limitations forced a top-down perspective and a rhythmic combat system that stripped away the scares. Despite this, the game’s narrative twists and the shocking “fake Leon” ending are still discussed in fan circles today.
The Multiplayer Struggles: Resistance and Umbrella Corps
Capcom has often struggled to translate Resident Evil’s tension into an online multiplayer format. Resident Evil Resistance, bundled with the Resident Evil 3 remake, offered an asymmetric 4v1 experience. While the concept of a “Mastermind” placing traps against “Survivors” was solid, the game suffered from severe balancing issues and unstable servers.
Even more controversial was Umbrella Corps, released for the 20th anniversary. It attempted to be a tactical, live-service shooter set in iconic RE locations like the RPD station. The game was panned for its clunky controls and its complete lack of a coherent story. However, for those who want to see a different, more action-heavy side of the Umbrella lore, it offers a bizarre, fast-paced glimpse into the world of bio-warfare mercenaries.
The Controversial Mainline Entries: RE6 and RE3 Remake
Resident Evil 6 is perhaps the most divisive mainline entry. It aimed for a massive global scale, featuring four separate campaigns and a star-studded cast including Leon, Chris, Ada, and newcomer Jake Muller. Critics felt the game leaned too far into Michael Bay-style action, losing its survival horror roots. Despite this, the sheer amount of content and the fluid combat system make it a fantastic “guilty pleasure” co-op experience.
The Resident Evil 3 (2020) remake also faced significant backlash. While the character models and visuals were stunning, fans felt the game was too short. Iconic sections of the original game, such as the Clock Tower and the “Live Selection” choice system, were cut entirely. Nevertheless, the high-octane chases with Nemesis and the tighter, action-focused pacing still provide a thrilling ride for a single afternoon.
The lowest-rated titles that still offer a unique experience include:
- Resident Evil Dead Aim: A better attempt at the “Gun Survivor” style with a surprisingly cool cruise ship atmosphere.
- Resident Evil Operation Raccoon City: A tactical shooter that allows you to play as Umbrella’s security team during the 1998 outbreak.
- Resident Evil RE:Verse: A chaotic deathmatch featuring heroes and B.O.W.s that, while short-lived, was a fun celebration of the series’ roster.
Every game in this list was built with a vision, even if that vision didn’t perfectly align with the audience’s expectations. As we look forward to the recently announced Story Expansion for Resident Evil Requiem, it’s worth looking back at these cult classics to see how the franchise has learned from its mistakes.
